The Nihilist's Missing Premise
The Nihilist's Missing Premise Two bounded arguments against temporal nihilism and despair-driven withdrawal Argument note · finitude, permanence, meaning, value, nihilistic withdrawal, self-defeat, and scope Andraž Đurič Version 1 · July 2026 Abstract This note targets two related but distinct forms of nihilistic reasoning. The first is temporal nihilism : because a life, relationship, achievement, experience, civilization, or all organized complexity eventually ends, it is therefore meaningless or valueless. That conclusion requires a bridge premise: only what is temporally infinite, permanently preserved, or permanently difference-making can possess the relevant value or meaning. Finitude does not itself establish that premise. Unless the premise is defended independently, the conclusion does not follow. If it is established, this first objection fails. The second target is despair-driven nihilistic withdrawal : an...